For some reason, I remember my house being overrun by peanut butter cookies last year, although no one else does. They really aren't my favorite--I think the peanut butter and the sugar mixture is an awfully odd flavor, but I still like them in moderation. Plus, when they're a Smitten Kitchen recipe, how can I say no? My friends and I live by Smitten Kitchen's updates.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookies